One for those New Year Resolutions here.
A recruitment business can have great billers and a terrible culture. And sometimes, they’re the same people.
And that’s damaging lead to growth, as well as retention. The wrong behaviours and values can stifle good people, great initiatives and engagement.
At a networking event today, everybody talked about the “bad apple”- people they hung on to because they were great billers, because they were the only person with XX expertise, and so on.
And every single one said they wish they had exited that person sooner.
Almost every recruitment business claims to have values. Integrity. Excellence. Teamwork. Passion.
Lovely words. But what do they actually mean?
More importantly, would you recognise someone demonstrating them? And would you challenge someone who wasn’t, even if they were your top biller?
Because values aren’t what you put on your website. They’re what you tolerate, reward and promote.
The 10-person tipping point
In the early stages of a recruitment business, culture is largely dictated by the founder. They set the standards, make the decisions and influence almost everything.
But somewhere around 10 employees, things change.
I call this Phase Two: the point where the owner can no longer control every conversation, decision or behaviour.
This is precisely when values need to become a shared responsibility, developed and owned by the whole business, rather than imposed by the founder.
Otherwise, culture develops by accident. And that’s dangerous.
Stop using nouns. Start describing behaviours.
Forget ‘Integrity’. Try ‘We tell clients and candidates the truth, even when it’s uncomfortable.’
Instead of ‘Teamwork’, try ‘We share information and opportunities rather than protecting our own commission.’
Instead of ‘Excellence’, try ‘We challenge ourselves to improve the quality of every shortlist.’
These are behaviours people can recognise, demonstrate and evaluate.
And there’s a crucial distinction: being good at recruitment doesn’t automatically make someone a good employee.
Someone might generate £300,000 in gross profit while undermining colleagues, mistreating candidates or damaging client relationships.
Are they genuinely an asset?
Stop measuring people solely by their billings
Values should influence recruitment, probation reviews, appraisals, promotions and reward decisions.
And yes, potentially decisions about whether someone remains in the business.
I frequently hear recruitment leaders say they ‘interview for values’.
Really? How?
Too often it’s an instinctive judgement about whether someone seems a good fit.
There are specific profiling tools that can help assess relevant characteristics, although they need careful selection and interpretation. Equally, structured, evidence-based interviews, using consistent questions and scoring criteria, can provide a much more reliable assessment.
The important thing is having a defensible process, not relying on gut feeling.
The cost of getting it wrong is increasing
Recruiters already carry substantial employment costs: salaries, commission, employer National Insurance, pensions, training and management time.
And from 1 January 2027, ordinary unfair dismissal protection will generally apply after just six months rather than two years, while the cap on compensatory awards will be removed.
That makes clear expectations, documented assessments and fair management processes even more important.
Values aren’t a soft HR exercise. They’re a commercial risk management tool.
Make your values earn their keep
I’ve developed bespoke, structured sessions specifically for recruitment businesses to define or redefine their values, with practical implementation and reference tools to embed them into everyday management, recruitment and performance assessment.
Not another set of inspirational words for the wall.
A framework for deciding who belongs in your business, who progresses, and what good really looks like.
If your values aren’t influencing decisions, they’re not really values.
Contact me to find out more about how we can make yours work.
Alison Humphries Hon FREC
Recruitment Leadership
www.recruitmentleadership.co.uk
About the Author: Alison Humphries Hon (FREC) is the founder of Recruitment Leadership Ltd, a strategic consultancy for the recruitment industry. With 40 years of experience, including leading teams, launching divisions in listed companies and personally negotiating global contracts worth over £120 million per year – Alison has helped hundreds of recruitment businesses maximise performance, enter new markets and prepare for sale. Learn more about Alison.
If you’d like to make more money from the business you’re already winning, get in touch with Alison to discuss how she can help.


